Everyone seems to agree that this fall’s mid-term election will be a real barn-burner. How could it not be? What is happening now — and why politics seems so intense — is nothing less than a redefinition of what America means.
Through all of American history — until, well, now — America has been a white Christian country with minorities. The status of those minorities has always been at the discretion of the white majority. Even at their most generous, that majority had the right — more important than the right, they had the power — to set conditions for full membership in the community. And the condition they generally set was acceptance of the majority’s beliefs and values — or at least a respect for the special status of the majority culture.
There has been resistance from the minorities since the beginning, but over the last fifty years, those of us who don’t fit into the traditional majority have decided to say, “enough.” We are here by right, and we don’t need to meet anyone’s “conditions.”
Not only that, but with the coming of the non-white majority, and people getting used to increased personal freedom, that conservative majority isn’t a majority anymore. White Christians are just one more minority group, entitled to live by their own rules, but not to impose those rules on anyone else nor to claim any kind of special status.
It’s no wonder the conservative white Christians, the self-styled “Real Americans,” are screaming about the “Founders.” They need a fixed point from which to attack the changes of the 20th century — and, for that matter, the 19th. They need a time when the status of their culture was safe from challenge.
And nothing makes them angrier than someone who points out a dark side of the “Founding.” They love to talk about “taxation without representation.” (They like it so much they even want to claim they’re victims of it today.) They don’t want to talk about how much of the colonists’ displeasure with the British government was because it was at least trying to protect the Indians from dispossession, or because it was looking like the British courts were about to declare slavery illegal.
Personally, I don’t look back to the 18th century “Founding” as the root of the country to which I belong. I look back to the liberation struggles of the 20th century — women’s suffrage, the labor movement, the various civil-rights movements, women’s liberation, environmentalism … and, yes, the sexual revolution.
I’ll hazard a guess that in the deep future — after everyone now alive is gone — Americans will look back to the 18th century “Founding” much as contemporary Brits look back to the Norman Conquest. It’s incomparably important in their history. (Ours too, for that matter.) but they don’t celebrate it. The bad guys won.
And the more the Americans of the new majority get the F—ing Fathers thrown in their faces every time they want to do something, the sooner that day will come.
So who are the real “Real Americans”? They are nonwhites — and white people who don’t have a problem with racial equality. They are non-Christians — and Christians prepared to practice religious tolerance. They are people who don’t follow traditional “family values” — or who do, but don’t object if their neighbors don’t.
That’s the country I belong to.